Why Bank Overdrafts May Be a Bad Deal For You

Many banks actively encourage their clients with low balances to overdraw their accounts. That means, if the customer writes a check or uses her debit card and has insufficient funds in the account, the bank clears the check by granting a temporary overdraft (a short-term loan), up to a specific limit. The customer is saved from the problems of bounced checks or interrupted shopping sprees.

Sounds like a good deal for the customers, right? That's what the banks say. They claim overdrafts are an added convenience to customers.

The truth is, they're often a very bad deal for the customers. Here's why.

When a bank grants a regular line of credit, the interest charged may be up to say, 20% or so. However, for overdrafts, banks don't charge interest -- they charge a flat fee on each transaction. This fee does not depend on the value of the transaction.

Let's see how that works. Overdraft plans fees may be as high as $35 per check. We'll assume a more conservative fee of $20 per check. If you have four checks totaling $200 that have insufficient funds against them and the bank automatically activates the overdraft and clears those checks, you will owe $80 in overdraft charges.

Unlike revolving lines of credit which you can repay at your convenience, an overdraft has to be settled in just a few days. Let's say the bank allows you to run the overdraft for 14 days.

A loan of $200 for 14 days incurring charges of $80 translates into an Annual Percentage Rate (APR) of 1043%!

A "convenience" for customers? Not at these rates.

What does this remind you of? It reminds me of payday loans and cash advances. Those are the other forms of lending which charge you such sky-high APRs. In fact, if you choose to repay a cash advance on due date and not roll it over, you'll likely be charged far less than what the banks charge you for an overdraft.

It gets even worse. Banks have software that ensures that your largest value checks and debits get processed first. There may be some logic to that. However, this arrangement also means that when there are insufficient funds in your account, instead of paying one overdraft charge on one large check, you pay several charges on several smaller checks!

Plus, most customers don't even realize that they are overdrawn until the bank notifies them about it.

Consumer advocates say that banks are perfectly aware that many people barely make it from payday to payday. These customers typically have very low balances. Rather than offer them a service that would be in their interests, banks extract high fees from them to cover bounced checks.

If you are caught short between paychecks, consider arranging funds from other sources rather than turn to overdraft protection. The best solution to the problem is to systematically build up cash balances so that you don't face such a situation in the first place.

About the Author

Prakash Menon is a financial expert and writer specializing in managing personal debt and providing wealth building solutions. He has written on signature loans, personal debt management and other topics.

Banks on sticky wicket as textile sector loans on verge of turning bad Economic Times Now companies say they can't even pay interest on Rs 50000 crore in working capital loans. Up to 15% of loans to this industry are stressed and the number is rising fast. In today's precarious times, such a gaping hole could be the last straw for banks ... Bad loans rise at a faster clipLivemint Banks ask borrowers to cover their personal loans, overdraft facilitiesBusiness Standard Rise in NPA makes PSU banks lag private peersmydigitalfc.com Hindu Business Line all 12 news articles »

Bad loans were legally hidden as Lenihan made pledge Irish Times The flaw allowed banks to conceal substantial losses on troubled loans. It reversed the pre-2005 rules under which banks were forced to recognise immediately, losses on bad lending. From 2005 onwards banks were required to wait until the borrower ... and more »

INDABA: Global Mining, Metals Loans, Bonds Rose In 2011 As IPOs Faded -E&Y Fox Business Bank loans for 2011 totaled $187 billion, with about half related to refinancing, consultancy-and-accounting firm Ernst and Young said. Bank loans were up 2% on the year while corporate-bond issues were up 16% on the year at $83.8 billion. and more »

President Obama's student loan debt relief plan goes into effect early Daily Sundial By Irene Nesbitt Graduate students received financial assistance from President Obama's student loan debt relief plan last month. Originally, this was supposed take place on Jan. 2014, but in the midst of the tuition and loan crisis students will see ... and more »

SBA lending returns to pre-boom levels Washington Post A steady flow of new loans backed by the Small Business Administration in the Washington area is helping some institutions return to the pace of lending that was common in the pre-boom years. Through the three months ended Dec. and more »

Daily Mail

'Pay-day' loans used to fund plastic surgery: Website deals linked to 'good looks' Daily Mail By Vanessa Allen Pay-day loan firms came under fire yesterday for offering unsecured lending arrangements to fund cosmetic surgery. Glossy websites promote short-term pay-day deals alongside unsecured loans to pay for operations including face lifts, ... and more »

Loan growth likely to moderate this year The Sun Daily PETALING JAYA (Jan 6, 2012): Housing loan growth continued to expand at a robust pace in December, although the true test of the sector's strength will be in January when tougher lending measures by the banking sector to control ballooning household ...

Change.org

Online Campaign Prompts Sallie Mae to Change Fee Policy for Loan Suspensions New York Times On Thursday, three months after Bank of America backed down from imposing a $5 monthly debit card fee in response to an online Change.org petition that collected 300000 signers, Sallie Mae, the nation's largest private student-loan provider, ... Sallie Mae will credit $50 fee to suspend paymentsSan Francisco Chronicle Jobless grads rap Sallie Mae over loan feeMarketWatch Student borrowers fight Sallie Mae's 'jobless penalty'Monmouth Daily Review Atlas all 202 news articles »

PR Web (press release)

Payday loan advocate omits pertinent facts Columbia Daily Tribune What she failed to say is that her group is funded by the payday loan industry, the same group that sent threatening letters to churches across the state. Churches are speaking out in favor of capping the rate because they are all too familiar with the ... Same Day Payday Loan Introduces New “How it Works” ResourcePR Web (press release) all 7 news articles »

Banks to take a hit on US home loans Financial Times The Obama administration, which recently announced the formation of a new state and federal unit to investigate alleged frauds involving home loans and mortgage-backed securities, intends to use the threat of litigation against large US financial ... HUD Secretary Expects “Substantial” Payment of Foreclosure Fraud Settlement ...Firedoglake all 2 news articles »