Business Credit Scoring: Is It a Killer Application or Application Killer?

In his 1968 seminal novel, 2001: A Space Odyssey, Arthur Clark introduced HAL, a spaceship computer with artificial intelligence. Mission engineers designed HAL to carry out an array of technical orders to safeguard the ship's mission. HAL operated flawlessly until it reported the failed operation of a ship system that was operating perfectly. Rather than correct the mistake, HAL's logic dictated that it would be more efficient to kill the ship's crew. Ever the polite computer, HAL killed quickly and quietly until it was unplugged by the sole remaining crewmember, Dave Bowman.

Many small business owners believe that HAL's progeny are carrying out HAL's murderous mission in the small business credit arena. Computers now make important credit decisions for major banks and financing companies. Each day in the U.S., computers with fancy algorithms score thousands of small business credit transactions. Though credit-scoring models work well for most small companies, many believe these systems, like HAL, have run amuck. Routinely, transactions with low scores are turned down and applicants are notified of the decision by computer-generated rejection letters.

By gaining a better understanding of the credit scoring process, you may be able to help your firm maneuver in the new world of credit scoring. Here are some key points about business credit scoring worth noting:

1. Credit scoring automates the credit evaluation process. Credit providers use these systems to speed up loan processing, to cut processing costs, to quickly adjust rates and terms to match credit risks, and to add a high degree of objectivity to credit decisions.

2. Credit scoring is a predictive system based on statistical modeling. Scoring systems are designed to forecast whether borrowers will be successful in repaying loans. Many systems use up to 20 factors to evaluate credit worthiness.

3. Many lenders and leasing companies use credit scoring for business transactions under $100,000. Over 90% of major credit providers use credit-scoring systems on transactions below $ 50,000.

4. A pioneer and leading credit scoring service, Fair Isaac and Company, researched statistical credit modeling in the 1980s. They determined that the personal credit behavior of a company's key principals/owners is a strong predictor of their business credit behavior. Simply stated, a business owner who pays personal bills on time generally will cause his/her company to pay bills on time.

5. The Fair Isaac scoring model produces business credit scores ranging from 50 to 350. Credit providers usually consider a business credit score above 220 to be a good risk. They consider a score of less than 175 to be a high risk.

6. The overriding factor in business credit scoring is the credit history of the business owners or the key principals. In addition, there are other factors related to the owners'/principals' personal credit profiles used to score small business transactions

7. Business-related credit factors scored include: the company's time in business; company size; industry; form of company organization; history of paying bills on time; business net worth; average bank balances; ratio of debt service to cash flow; and recent judgments, bankruptcies or agency collections.

8. Many large lenders, such as Well Fargo Bank and Bank of America, have developed their own predictive business credit models. Several have even fine-tuned the Fair Isaac model to better meet their needs and preferences.

9. If your firm is rejected for credit based on a scoring model, ask the lender to explain the rejection. Some lenders will reconsider if requested, but may require additional credit information.

10. Some lenders have special pools for higher risk credits. They usually charge higher rates and offer terms that are less advantageous than for high-scoring transactions. Others may ask for credit enhancements to grant approval, such as additional collateral or outside guarantees.

11. Here are ten ways to improve business credit scores:

* Improve the credit habits and profiles of the key principals or business owners

* Pay all back taxes

* Settle outstanding liens and judgments

* Pay bills on time and be consistent with payments

* Eliminate supplier disputes by settling with any suppliers or former employees

* Sell or factor accounts receivable to improve cash flow

* Establish your firm's credit record by registering with the Secretary of State where your business is incorporated

* Try to improve individual and company credit for at least twelve months

* Buy from vendors who report activity to the major credit bureaus

* Set up automatic account debiting with creditors to help eliminate the possibility of paying slow

Credit scoring is not designed to predict individual loan performance with certainty. Rather, these systems do a great job of quantifying risks for groups of borrowers with similar characteristics. A disadvantage of credit scoring systems is that they are easy to misapply. If the lender's customers don't share characteristics and behavior patterns with the model's underlying base group of credits, then reminiscent of HAL, many transactions with great potential may be eliminated.

If your firm doesn't score well under a scoring model used by a major lender, you may face an uphill battle for credit approval. Some smaller credit providers try to differentiate themselves by not using scoring models. Instead, they actually listen to borrowers, sort out unusual circumstances and use old-fashion human judgment to make credit decisions. One of these lenders might make sense for your firm.

George Parker is a Director and Executive Vice President of Leasing Technologies International, Inc. ("LTI"). He is responsible for overseeing the company's marketing and financing efforts. One of the co-founders of LTI, Mr. Parker has been involved in secured lending and equipment financing for over twenty years. Mr. Parker is an industry leader, frequent panelist and author of several articles pertaining to equipment financing.

Headquartered in Wilton, CT, LTI is a leasing firm specializing nationally in direct equipment financing and vendor leasing programs for emerging growth and later-stage, venture capital backed companies. More information about LTI is available at http://www.ltileasing.com.

Bad loans were legally hidden as Lenihan made pledge Irish Times The flaw allowed banks to conceal substantial losses on troubled loans. It reversed the pre-2005 rules under which banks were forced to recognise immediately, losses on bad lending. From 2005 onwards banks were required to wait until the borrower ... and more »

INDABA: Global Mining, Metals Loans, Bonds Rose In 2011 As IPOs Faded -E&Y Fox Business Bank loans for 2011 totaled $187 billion, with about half related to refinancing, consultancy-and-accounting firm Ernst and Young said. Bank loans were up 2% on the year while corporate-bond issues were up 16% on the year at $83.8 billion. and more »

President Obama's student loan debt relief plan goes into effect early Daily Sundial By Irene Nesbitt Graduate students received financial assistance from President Obama's student loan debt relief plan last month. Originally, this was supposed take place on Jan. 2014, but in the midst of the tuition and loan crisis students will see ... and more »

SBA lending returns to pre-boom levels Washington Post A steady flow of new loans backed by the Small Business Administration in the Washington area is helping some institutions return to the pace of lending that was common in the pre-boom years. Through the three months ended Dec. and more »

Daily Mail

'Pay-day' loans used to fund plastic surgery: Website deals linked to 'good looks' Daily Mail By Vanessa Allen Pay-day loan firms came under fire yesterday for offering unsecured lending arrangements to fund cosmetic surgery. Glossy websites promote short-term pay-day deals alongside unsecured loans to pay for operations including face lifts, ... and more »

Change.org

Online Campaign Prompts Sallie Mae to Change Fee Policy for Loan Suspensions New York Times On Thursday, three months after Bank of America backed down from imposing a $5 monthly debit card fee in response to an online Change.org petition that collected 300000 signers, Sallie Mae, the nation's largest private student-loan provider, ... Sallie Mae will credit $50 fee to suspend loan paymentsWashington Post Jobless grads rap Sallie Mae over loan feeMarketWatch Student borrowers fight Sallie Mae's 'jobless penalty'Monmouth Daily Review Atlas all 202 news articles »

Bad loans rise at a faster clip Livemint Among the relatively large banks, gross NPAs of at least four banks—ICICI Bank Ltd, Union Bank of India, Central Bank of India and UCO Bank—in the December quarter were between 3.82% and 3.33% of their loan books. After setting aside money, ... Banks on sticky wicket as textile sector loans on verge of turning badEconomic Times Banks ask borrowers to cover their personal loans, overdraft facilitiesBusiness Standard Rise in NPA makes PSU banks lag private peersmydigitalfc.com Hindu Business Line all 12 news articles »

Banks to take a hit on US home loans Financial Times The Obama administration, which recently announced the formation of a new state and federal unit to investigate alleged frauds involving home loans and mortgage-backed securities, intends to use the threat of litigation against large US financial ... HUD Secretary Expects “Substantial” Payment of Foreclosure Fraud Settlement ...Firedoglake all 3 news articles »

PR Web (press release)

Payday loan advocate omits pertinent facts Columbia Daily Tribune What she failed to say is that her group is funded by the payday loan industry, the same group that sent threatening letters to churches across the state. Churches are speaking out in favor of capping the rate because they are all too familiar with the ... Same Day Payday Loan Introduces New “How it Works” ResourcePR Web (press release) all 7 news articles »

UK bank lending to shrink in 2012 -Ernst & Young Reuters * UK bank loans to shrink by 2.2 pct in 2012 -E&Y ITEM club * Payday loan companies set to benefit as banks cut credit -E&Y LONDON Feb 6 (Reuters) - Total bank lending in Britain is set to shrink for the first time since 2009 this year, and the lack of ... UK Bank Lending To Contract In 2012: ITEM ClubNASDAQ SMEs hit as bank lending slidesTelegraph.co.uk all 6 news articles »